L o a d i n g

Do Markets Really Care Who Wins the Midterms?

Coeus Perspectives • 28 Oct 2026

November 8, 1994. 4 p.m. Chicago.

It is a gloomy afternoon. Rain, drizzle and fog have made an already short November day feel darker still. John and Margaret Whitaker have already turned on the lights. John closed his building-supplies business early and drove home well ahead of schedule in his all-American Buick. Margaret’s church council meeting has been postponed.

On the porch, the Stars and Stripes hangs wet and lifeless in the rain. On the table lies an open King James Bible. Psalm 31:24: “Be of good courage, and he shall strengthen your heart, all ye that hope in the LORD.”

Hope is something John and Margaret, lifelong Republicans, are certainly going to need. Confidence is something else. It is midterm election day and the mood inside the house is almost as gloomy as the weather outside. John throws another log on the fire in an attempt to make things a little cosier. In vain. John and Margaret have little faith that their party will take control of Congress. Zero, if you ask John. The political arithmetic looks merciless.

CBS is on. Dan Rather keeps returning with fresh election results.

And then, slowly but surely, something remarkable begins to happen. Republicans start winning one race after another. Seats that were not expected to fall begin to fall. What only hours earlier had seemed unlikely becomes possible. Possible becomes probable. And John and Margaret’s mood improves accordingly.

By 11 p.m. Chicago time, both chambers have been called for the Republicans.

The final tally will be 230 Republican seats to 204 Democratic seats in the House of Representatives, with one Independent, and 52 to 48 in the Senate. For the first time in forty years, the Republican Party controls the House. This political earthquake will soon have a name: The Republican Revolution.

“Would you like some more tea, dear?” Margaret asks. “Forget tea!” John disappears into the basement, returns with his best bottle of champagne and pulls the cork. “I bet my IBM shares open at least 10% higher tomorrow!”

*      *      *

In 1994, on the evening before the election, the Iowa Electronic Markets assigned Republicans only about a 20% chance of taking the House. So the final result was a genuine political surprise. And markets could react vividly to surprises.

In 2007, economists Erik Snowberg, Justin Wolfers and Eric Zitzewitz used precisely this kind of election-night shock in their study Party Influence in Congress and the Economy. Rather than simply comparing markets before and after an election, they used prediction markets, where contracts trade according to the perceived probability of a particular outcome, to track how political expectations changed as results arrived. 1994 was the perfect natural experiment.

There was also a clear market hypothesis to test. At the time, a Republican victory was generally associated with higher equity prices, higher interest rates and a stronger US dollar. So what did financial markets do while American politics was being turned upside down?

Zip, nothing, zero, nada, niente. The S&P 500 rose less than 0.40%. Oil gained 26 cents. The yen moved 0.174%, the German mark 0.196%, and the yield on the 10-year US Treasury did not move at all.

John might have been better off reaching for a good old bourbon. Maybe two.

Snowberg, Wolfers and Zitzewitz also studied other Congressional elections. Their broader conclusion was striking: changing the majority party in Congress appeared to have only around 10% to 30% of the financial-market impact of changing the party controlling the White House.

This brings us to November 3, 2026. Once again, every seat in the House and roughly one-third of the Senate will be contested. Once again, control of Congress could change hands.

Markets will be watching closely. So will we. But history offers some useful perspective. If one of the largest Congressional surprises of modern times could turn American politics upside down while moving the S&P 500 by practicably nothing, we should perhaps be careful not to confuse political drama with financial-market drama.

For Coeus Capital, therefore, the midterms are something to watch rather than a reason to set risk parameters to zero. Business as usual.